Free talk Everyone tells you not to go: Sam Cook at AUSA in Washington, and the panel that followed, for defence tech professionals. Watch free

Russia's Breaking Point: How Long Can Russia Keep Fighting?

Rob Lee says Russia's attrition rate is basically level with its recruitment rate, so it cannot form new units, and that where the breaking point sits, no one can say. He adds that Putin keeps commanders who send him false reports. Ievgen Malik says Russia hurries prisoner exchanges only for conscripts.

Updated

Key findings

  • Last year, Lee thinks, 80% of new recruits went straight in as combat replacements, so Russia could not build new units. (Rob Lee, listen)
  • Tanks in Russia's most sophisticated failed assault were taking 10 to 20 FPVs each before they were stopped. (Rob Lee, listen)
  • Russian units prepare reports of around 150 pages, and Ukraine lacks the analytical centres to do the same. (Dmytro Putiata, listen)
  • When Ukraine held Russian conscripts, the exchange came in one week, or two, three weeks maximum. (Ievgen Malik, listen)
  • The commander of the West Group of Forces told Putin Kupiansk was encircled and then taken, neither was true, and he is still in charge. (Rob Lee, listen)
  • Russian police officers are given a quota of one or two men a month to sign contracts, with a financial bonus if they hit it. (Rob Lee, listen)

The people in this topic

Can Russia recruit enough men to replace its losses?

Rob Lee says Russia is recruiting roughly enough to replace its losses and no more, through high pay, coercion and police quotas rather than a decree, so it cannot form new units, and nobody can say where its breaking point is.

  1. Can Russia Replace Its Losses? Rob Lee on RecruitmentRob Lee thinks 80% of Russia's recruits last year went in as combat replacements, and police get a quota of one or two men a month: covert mobilisation.

Is the Russian military learning from its failures?

Rob Lee says Russia is experimenting and learning at the tactical level, but that its system is not firing commanders for significant failures, which he counts as luck for Ukraine.

  1. How Many FPV Drones Stop a Tank? Rob Lee Was Told 10 to 20Rob Lee was told each Arena-M tank took 10 to 20 FPVs; one rolled over 16 mines and Azov Corps downed 27 Lancets. Dmytro Putiata on what Russia learned.
  2. Rob Lee on Why Putin Keeps the Generals Who Mislead HimPutin was told Kupiansk was encircled, then taken. Neither was true, and the commander kept his post. Rob Lee on why that flawed system helps Ukraine.

Why does Russia hurry prisoner exchanges only for conscripts?

Ievgen Malik says Russia tries to get conscripts back because of their mothers, while for a contract soldier, in his words, if you are in captivity, you are dead already.

  1. Ievgen Malik on Why Russia Only Hurries Swaps for ConscriptsOnce Ukraine held Kursk conscripts, swaps came within weeks, says ex-POW Ievgen Malik. Of 650 men in his prison, about 20 have come home.

Where these arguments come from

Stay in the loop

Never miss an episode

Get an email when a new episode drops. No spam, unsubscribe anytime.