Free talk Everyone tells you not to go: Sam Cook at AUSA in Washington, and the panel that followed, for defence tech professionals. Watch free

Ukraine's Deep Strike Campaign: What It Can and Cannot Do

Rob Lee says Ukraine has narrowed the deep-strike gap, sending more than 1,000 drones in a single night, yet only somewhere around 15% to 30% get through, and accuracy, not range, keeps Moscow targets off the list. Dmytro Putiata doubts the refinery strikes, which burn but keep working. Francis Farrell says middle strike works hardest in the south.

Updated

Key findings

  • Rob Lee says most deep-strike drones are defeated, and what gets through is somewhere around 15% to 30%. (Rob Lee, listen)
  • Dmytro Putiata says a struck refinery keeps working after the strike because the critical components are not being hit. (Dmytro Putiata, listen)
  • Rob Lee says Ukraine's GPS or INS-guided deep-strike drones are not that accurate: even with warehouses, they are missing them sometimes. (Rob Lee, listen)
  • By Russia's own internal figures, Rob Lee says, about 90% of Ukraine's middle strike drones that hit Crimea carry Starlink. (Rob Lee, listen)
  • Rob Lee prices a Hornet at $3,500 bare, around $5,000 with Starlink fitted, and the Blyskavka and Dart near $2,000. (Rob Lee, listen)
  • Dmytro Putiata says Russian depots that sat 60 to 80 kilometres from the front are now around 120 kilometres back, and expects Ukraine to force them to at least 200 kilometres. (Dmytro Putiata, listen)

The people in this topic

Do Ukraine's refinery strikes actually work?

Dmytro Putiata says refineries keep working after strikes because the critical components are missed, and that with four organisations running deep strike nobody is asking about the efficiency.

  1. Do Ukraine's Refinery Strikes Work? Lee and Putiata DisagreeOnly 15% to 30% of deep-strike drones get through, says Rob Lee. Dmytro Putiata on why burning refineries keep working, and who the fuel war favours.
  2. Who Runs Ukraine's Deep Strike? Rob Lee Counts FourRob Lee counts four bodies running Ukraine's deep strike: HUR, the SBU, the Unmanned Systems Forces and Special Operations. Dmytro Putiata on the cost.

Why doesn't Ukraine strike Moscow?

Rob Lee says accuracy, not range, is the limit, even though Ukraine has narrowed the deep-strike gap with packages of more than 1,000 drones in a single night.

  1. Why Doesn't Ukraine Strike Moscow? Rob Lee on AccuracyUkraine has at times sent over 1,000 drones in a night, yet Rob Lee says GPS-guided drones miss even warehouses, so key Moscow targets stay off the list.

Is Ukraine's middle strike campaign working?

Rob Lee says it has not produced a dramatic fall in Russian assaults but has clearly benefited Ukraine, pulling Russian interceptor teams back to guard main highways.

  1. Ukraine's Middle Strike Campaign: Rob Lee's VerdictRob Lee on Ukraine's middle strike campaign: Russian interceptor teams pulled back to guard highways, and Putiata says depots now sit around 120 km back.

How much does a Ukrainian strike drone cost?

Rob Lee puts a Hornet at $3,500 bare and the Blyskavka and Dart near $2,000, cheap enough to send thousands a month against a Russia without a comprehensive echelon system.

  1. Ukrainian Strike Drone Costs: Rob Lee Prices Dart to FP-2Rob Lee prices Ukraine's strike drones: Dart about $2,000, Hornet $3,500, FP-2 around $50,000. Dmytro Putiata puts Russia's Molniya at about $1,500.
  2. Why Russia Can't Stop Ukraine's Cheap Drones, by Rob LeeRob Lee: Russia lacks the echelon defence Ukraine built against Shaheds since October 2022, so thousands of cheap Hornets and Darts a month get through.

Rob Lee says it runs almost all UGVs, naval drones and many middle strike drones, yet it is not enabled in Russian territory and Russia has had some success jamming it over Crimea.

  1. Ukraine's Starlink Dependence: Rob Lee Calls It a CrutchAbout 90% of Ukraine's middle strike drones hitting Crimea carry Starlink, says Rob Lee. Dmytro Putiata calls relying on one link self-degradation.

Where these arguments come from

Stay in the loop

Never miss an episode

Get an email when a new episode drops. No spam, unsubscribe anytime.