Free talk Everyone tells you not to go: Sam Cook at AUSA in Washington, and the panel that followed, for defence tech professionals. Watch free

OSINT and the Ukraine War: Reading the Front Line

Rob Lee says the battlefield is better than it was a year ago but the war has not reached a turning point yet. Francis Farrell asks whether a worse picture is a real change on the battlefield or a correction to your own understanding. Dmytro Putiata notes the situation became better with even fewer resources in terms of men.

Updated

Key findings

  • The battlefield is better than it was a year ago, Rob Lee says, but the war has not reached a turning point yet. (Rob Lee, listen)
  • Ukraine now has even fewer resources in terms of men than in 2024, Dmytro Putiata says, and yet the situation became better. (Dmytro Putiata, listen)
  • For Ukraine, Dmytro Putiata says, a turning point would be to stop or minimise the Russian advance and minimise its losses, and so far Ukraine has only partly done it. (Dmytro Putiata, listen)
  • Before the invasion Russia moved something like 85% of its BTGs, by Rob Lee's own hedged recollection. (Rob Lee, listen)

The people in this topic

Is the war in Ukraine at a turning point?

Rob Lee says the battlefield is better than it was a year ago yet the war has not reached a turning point, and Francis Farrell sees nothing chaotic and nothing disastrous on a front that is harder but not reversing.

  1. Is the War at a Turning Point? Rob Lee Says Not YetRob Lee lists four ways the front beats a year ago yet calls no turning point. Dmytro Putiata and Francis Farrell on what one would actually look like.

How do you read Russia's war from what people on the ground saw?

Rob Lee read the 2022 buildup from civilian TikTok videos of trains, indicators that were objectively different and unprecedented, rather than from official warnings.

  1. Rob Lee on the OSINT That Exposed Russia's 2022 BuildupNo covering exercise, 85% of BTGs moved, Su-25s from Vladivostok: Rob Lee on the open-source signals that set 2022 apart from earlier war scares.
  2. Shaun Pinner on Mariupol: Why Russian Fire Never AdjustedShaun Pinner, the British Marine captured at Mariupol, on Russian mortars that never adjusted and steelworks assaults resent with 8, 20, then 30 men.
  3. Operational Security Is Earned, Jackie Tells Rob LeeKeeping Vivaldi off public maps was "absolutely vital," Third Corps adviser Jackie tells Rob Lee, and the corps earned that secrecy with results.

Where these arguments come from

Stay in the loop

Never miss an episode

Get an email when a new episode drops. No spam, unsubscribe anytime.